search for something...

search for something you might like...

Don’t Dictate To Me Alan Rider reflects on the Cherry Red reissue of punk stalwarts Penetration’s first two albums

Don’t Dictate To Me

Alan Rider reflects on the Cherry Red reissue of punk stalwarts Penetration’s first two albums

by Alan Rider, Contributing Editor
first published: November, 2024

approximate reading time: minutes

These were not just a bunch of mere snotty nosed council estate chancers, but skilled musicians composing competent rock music

Penetration
Moving Targets / Coming Up For Air
(Cherry Red Records)

Let’s face it, the first wave of punk bands were a very mixed bunch.  They ranged from the Who era Mod sounds of The Jam, and the Doors influenced rock of The Stranglers, through the snarlier Pub Rock of The Sex Pistols, punk’s very own version of The Bay City Rollers; The Ramones, Boy Band revolutionaries The Cash, sorry, The Clash!, to the gothic tones of The Banshees and the high-speed cartoon antics of The Damned. Then there were the second-string bands; X Ray Spex, Eater, Chelsea, Sham 69, UK Subs, The Vibrators, Lurkers, 999, The Adverts and…Penetration.  Whilst the top flight punk acts all fell over themselves to sign to major labels (very alternative!), had multiple hits, and generated iconic and original tracks that we can all remember and are now deemed classics of their time, the others managed one or (exceptionally) two standout tracks and the rest was filler.  Penetration certainly fitted within that second category, having released a brilliant single, ‘Don’t Dictate’ which everyone knows, yet also put out these two albums, now freshly remastered and reissued by Cherry Red, that I would struggle to recall a single other track from.

The whole concept of punk was a bit wonky from the start to be honest.  The media of the time created the story that they couldn’t play.  That was patently untrue.  There was also the impression given that they were going to smash the record business.  Also false, as with a very few exceptions (Mark Perry’s ATV being one) they were all desperate to abandon their DIY credentials, sign to a big label as fast as they could, and get on Top of the Pops with a hit record, just like any other pop band since the 60’s. What punk acts did have, though, was an anger, urgency, and visceral energy that had been totally lacking in the glam, pomp, and prog rock wilderness years, which were dominated by the likes of Queen, ELP, Yes, Deep Purple, and their ilk.  Penetration certainly had that energy in spades, as you can see from this video of their performance at Manchester's Electric Circus. 

As with all bands fronted by a female, the focus was on singer Pauline Murray with her shouty vocal stylings, and she certainly had the attitude, but that would do a sad disservice to the rest of the band.  These were not just a bunch of mere snotty nosed council estate chancers, but skilled musicians composing competent rock music full of things like chord changes, middle eights, harmonies, and all that.  Much of it sounds like what would soon be termed ‘New Wave’.  If anything, the weakest link, certainly on the first album, ‘Moving Targets’ is Pauline’s vocals, which sound quite strained for much of the album.  Standout track of course is the wonderful ‘Don’t Dictate’, which sounds even better here than I remember it, along with ‘Stone Heroes’, which also sounds vaguely familiar from the time.  The rest of the first CD is padded out by extra tracks and demos from the ‘Race Against Time’ bootleg album to bring it up to the required length for a reissue these days.  It’s a strong album though, full of great moments, and certainly stands up to the test of time.

Penetration album coverThe second CD comprises the second album, 1979’s ‘Coming Up For Air’, which is largely a very samey, weaker version of their debut, and was poorly received at the time. This does, however, contain a stonking live version of ‘Stone Heroes’ included as an extra track. Penetration split later in 79, with Murray going solo and also collaborating with punk superstar band, The Invisible Girls, which included former Penetration bassist Robert Blamire, Vini Reilly from The Durutti Column, and John Maher from the Buzzcocks on drums, and was produced by Martin Hannett.  Needless to say, Penetration didn’t stay split for ever and re-formed in 2001. Fourteen years later they even produced a third album and continue to tread the punk nostalgia circuit to this day.

Listening back to this, it is clear that Penetration definitely had a pretty good first album in them, but probably no more, and unless you are a completist, you could satisfy yourself with owning just that.  There is little in the way of extra sleeve notes or exclusives here to tempt you either. Penetration had none of the controversy or star quality of their peers to draw you in, and as a ‘box set’ this is little more than a reissue double with minimal frills really. As a historical document it does, however, act as a reminder of the wide range of diverse acts that were shoehorned together under the punk banner, largely because they appeared live on the same bill (don’t forget, at one time The Police were even regarded as a punk band just because they had short dyed hair and played the Marquee!) and illustrates just how hugely varied the music scene of the late 70s and early 80s was.


Essential Information:
Penetration - Moving Targets / Coming Up For Air is out on 6th December on Cherry Red Records and is available to pre-order from their store here

Main image: Cardiff Top Rank, 10th October 1979

Alan Rider
Contributing Editor

Alan Rider is a Norfolk based writer and electronic musician from Coventry, who splits his time between excavating his own musical past and feeding his growing band of hedgehogs, usually ending up combining the two. Alan also performs in Dark Electronic act Senestra and manages the indie label Adventures in Reality.


about Alan Rider »»

Pete Williams web banner

RECENT STORIES

RANDOM READS

All About and Contributors

HELP OUTSIDELEFT

Outsideleft exists on a precarious no budget budget. We are interested in hearing from deep and deeper pocket types willing to underwrite our cultural vulture activity. We're not so interested in plastering your product all over our stories, but something more subtle and dignified for all parties concerned. Contact us and let's talk. [HELP OUTSIDELEFT]

WRITE FOR OUTSIDELEFT

If Outsideleft had arms they would always be wide open and welcoming to new writers and new ideas. If you've got something to say, something a small dank corner of the world needs to know about, a poem to publish, a book review, a short story, if you love music or the arts or anything else, write something about it and send it along. Of course we don't have anything as conformist as a budget here. But we'd love to see what you can do. Write for Outsideleft, do. [SUBMISSIONS FORM HERE]

WRITERS thru' the Years

Agata Makiela, Alan Devey, Alan Rider, Alex V. Cook, Ancient Champion, Andy Allison, Annemiek, Becca Kelly, Belle Plankton, Bruce Bailey, Caiomhin Millar, Cassie Thomas, Chantal, Cheiron Coelho, Chris Connolly, Christian Present, Damon Hayhurst, Dan Breen, Danny Rose, David Hackney, David O'Byrne, Denni Boyd, Dirty Lillie, DJ Fuzzyfelt, Dr. Rich, Dr. Richard Bennett, Duncan Jones, Erin, Erin Pipes, Erin Scott, Gracey Babs, Graham Baker, Guilaine Arts, H.xx, Hamilton High, Henderson Downing, Holly Martins, J. Charreaux, J.Lee, Jay Lewis, Jaycentee, Jennifer Lynn, Jenny McCann, Jeremy Gluck, Jez Collins, Joe Ambrose, John Robinson, Jonathan Thornton, Julie O, Karl Morgan, Katherine Pargeter, Kelsey Osgood, Kevin McHugh, Kiah Cranston, Kleo Kay, Lake, Lee Paul, Luke Skinner, Malcolm, Marek Pytel, Mark Piggott, Martin Devenney, Meave Haughey, Michelle Williams, Mike Fox, mindy strouse, Neil Campbell, Neil Scott, Ogglypoogly, OL House Writer, Pam, Paul Burns, Paul Hawkins, Paul Mortimer, Paul Quigley, Peter Williams, Pixie McMowat, Pixievic, Rene Williams, Richard John Walker, Rick Casson, Rikki Stein, Ronan Crinion, Rowena Murphy, Ruby Lake, Ryan 'RJO' Stewart, Samantha Charles, Seth Sherwood, Shane O'Reilly, Sheridan Coyle, Sofia Ribeiro Willcox, Sophia Satchell-Baeza, Spanish Pantalones, Speedie John, Spencer Kansa, Steve McCarthy, The Conversation, Tim London, Tim Sparks, Tony Fletcher, Toon Traveller, Trevi, Urs Lerch, Wayne Dean-Richards, and founders, Alarcon & Lamontpaul

OUTSIDELEFT UNIVERSE

Last Night of the LTB Showrooms
OUTSIDELEFT Night Out
weekend

outsideleft content is not for everyone